The Hardest Thanks (On Being Broken Bread)

November 27, 2014

“In everything give thanks; for this is God’s will for you in Christ Jesus.”1 Thessalonians 5:18

It was “Takk for Alt” at our little country church.

Takk for Alt is Norwegian for “Thanks for Everything,” and it has long been the tradition at our 125-year-old church — where gray-haired farmers share pews with diapered babies and their mamas. Every November, around Thanksgiving, we celebrate the annual tradition with a Sunday meal.

But before the catered dinner, we always feast on Word and Sacrament.

So there we were, packed into our small sanctuary. And there I was, trembling at the pulpit to deliver a few words. Pastor had asked if I’d share something I wrote about gratitude.

So I stood there, nervously reading from a post-it note, about what it might mean to be thankful in ALL things.

“Be thankful in ALL things. All Things,” I read from my notes. “That’s what the Bible says. ALL things. Not just the smiling things and the wished-for things. The Bible says be thankful in all things. Even the hard things, the grotesque things, the things never-wanted, the things of death and grief and pain and sorrow that make you wonder if you can stand to live another day. How to be thankful like that? Is it really possible for a mortal to be thankful in all things? ‘In everything give thanks,’ Paul wrote. He didn’t say to be thankful FOR all things. But He absolutely said to be thankful IN all things. I want to be able to do that — just as Christ did when he lifted the bread, broke it and gave thanks, saying, ‘This is my body, given for you.”

I stepped down and walked back to my seat.

The night before, I had written those words on my blog, so that I might believe them heart-deep. Any sermon I ever “preach” on my blog, is really — at its core — a self-sermon to my trembling, stumbling self.

I want to live the words I write, not only with my pen, but with my whole being.

And I wanted to believe that Takk for Alt is real. I wanted to posess the ability to give thanks in all things.

Sure, we celebrate Takk for Alt year after year, this thankfulness for everything.

But what if Takk for Alt was only a nice catch-phrase, a reason to share a catered meal as a church family? And what if Thanksgiving Day was just an excuse to eat turkey and Mom’s stuffing, before taking a trytophan-induced nap in front of the television? What if Thanksgiving was merely another day off, conveniently timed to set up the Christmas tree and find the ceramic nativity in a cardboard box somewhere down by the furnace?

And this: When we say we give thanks, do we really only mean the good things? Or, like our Savior on the night He was betrayed, could we really give thanks in all things, every single day?


Later, after the pastor’s sermon, we ate our catered meal. Around the fellowship hall, I mentally catalogued my gratitude. This is the easy part of Takk for Alt. There were many blessings to count. I watched how people leaned into one another, laughing. Rosie brought over more coffee. Someone said they’d been praying for my ill daughter, a kindness that brought me to tears. I smiled, watching two friends — like real sisters — sharing one pumpkin dessert. This is the sort of thing you do at family tables. And I was thankful that we were like family.

But what about the other, harder half of Takk for Alt?

After the tables were cleared, we headed over to the sanctuary for our annual meeting. We discussed several new mission projects, and that was exciting. Again, more easy-thanksgiving.

But it wasn’t until the meeting was nearly adjourned when the fullness of the “everything” in Takk for Alt would come to pass. It wasn’t planned by any of us. It just … happened.

Before the meeting adjourned, a woman in the back row stood up. Her wobbly voice rose above the crowd: “I want to tell you how much it meant to me,” she said, “when you gave us a ‘love gift’ of money after the fire. And how you’ve welcomed us here in this church.”

And so began a series of spontaneous praise — a thank offering of the hardest things.

An elderly couple raised their voices next, expressing thanks to God when a separate fire destroyed buildings on their farm, flames coming within inches of the house. Much was lost, but they were grateful for what was spared.

Another woman stood up, giving thanks for all the people who comforted her in her time of mourning.

And on and on it went, people expressing Takk for Alt, not from the mountaintop, but from deep within their very own valleys.

I witnessed it right there under that country steeple in our tiny house of God, out between the harvested fields of Iowa. I witnessed Christ coming alive in our thanks — Him lifting the bread, saying “this is my body.” And we were His body, broken and thankful, laying down our Takk for Alt saucer under a full cup of praise.

“Perhaps it takes a purer faith to praise God for unrealized blessings than for those we once enjoyed or those we enjoy now.”A.W. Tozer

About the Author
  • Jennifer Dukes Lee is the author of Love Idol, an invitation to live in the approval of God alone. She is a storyteller and grace dweller from Inwood, Iowa, blogging at She is a community editor for and a writer for Dayspring’s (in)courage.

What are your thoughts about this topic?
We welcome your ideas and questions about the topics considered here. If you would like to receive others' comments and respond by email, please check the box below the comment form when you submit your own comments.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

There are currently no comments. Why don't you kick things off?